Al-Qaida speaks. Is anyone still listening?

Posted on Monday, September 08, 2008 6:40 PM ET
Filed Under:

By Jim Popkin, NBC News Senior Investigative Producer

What if the al-Qaida deputy spoke, and nobody listened? That's essentially what happened today when the propaganda division of the terrorist group released its latest video--complete with a major new speech by the al-Qaida deputy, Dr. Ayman al-Zawahiri--celebrating the anniversary of the 9-11 attacks.

Al-Qaida released the new 90-minute tape to the Al Jazeera television network, played select portions of it throughout the day. But the tape has received scant attention in the United States, especially compared to recent 9-11 anniversaries.

Terrorism analysts say that Americans--and American media outlets--are ignoring al-Qaida messages at their own peril. For many Americans, terrorism concerns are "falling off the radar, as al-Qaida has been silent in the USA (and much of the West) since 9-11," said Michael Sheehan, the former counter-terrorism official for the State Department and the City of New York. "Foreign attacks are mostly background noise. This is troublesome, for if we lose our focus they will attack us again at home," said Sheehan, who is now an NBC News terrorism analyst.

Robert Grenier, the former CIA counter-terrorism official and former CIA station chief in Islamabad, agreed. "We probably overreacted initially" to al-Qaida threats after the 9-11 attacks, Grenier said, "and we are under-reacting now." He said that while al-Qaida has suffered setbacks in recent years, it is resurgent along the Pakistan-Afghanistan border and is still extremely dangerous. He said Zawahiri's messages should not be discounted. "This man, unlike Bin Laden, is still an active terrorist. What he has to say to the faithful" still matters, Grenier said.

So what did Zawahiri say?
As the wire services reported, Zawahiri said Tehran was "cooperating with the Americans in occupying Iraq and Afghanistan." He slammed Iran for recognizing the two governments. He also criticized the Shiites for not calling for a jihad in Iraq against the "Crusader occupier." (In militant postings, "crusaders" is shorthand for U.S. troops in Iraq.)

"The guardian of Muslims in Tehran is cooperating with the Americans in occupying Iraq and Afghanistan and recognizes the two hireling governments there," al-Zawahiri said. Zawahiri has been increasingly singling out Iran and Shiites in his messages, most recently in April, describing the "Persians" as the enemy of Arabs and complicit in the occupation of Iraq.

The new video by As-Sahab, the terror group's propaganda arm, also featured clips of al-Qaida operations on various fronts, including Iraq, Afghanistan and Somalia, with prominent figures from the movement discoursing on their accomplishments over the year, Al-Jazeera said.

The U.S. Response:
A U.S. counter-terrorism official tells NBC News that U.S. agencies are mindful of the anniversary.  “The anniversary of September 11 serves as a solemn reminder of what we know to be the case. That is, we face the constant threat of terrorism and are working hard to prevent attacks against Americans and our allies," the official said. "This is a serious challenge for the nation, and we’re working hard to confront it.”

Complacency?
Ben Venzke, who analyzes videotaped terrorism statements for IntelCenter, said that Americans are becoming dangerously complacent about terrorism. He said he is reminded of the weeks before the 9-11 attacks, when the public (and media) were focusing on shark attacks and the latest turns in the Chandra Levy murder mystery. "If there's an attack, it's going to be out of the blue and blindside us," Venzke said. "If we could just manage to keep our attention span," he said, Americans would be better able to put any possible terrorist attack into perspective.

"They [terrorists] stay patient and focused, and we become an easier and easier target," Venzke said.

NBC News terrorism analyst Evan Kohlmann says, if Americans have become blasé about terrorist statements, it's partially Zawahiri's fault. "He keeps rehashing the same set of basic issues over and over again," Kohlmann said. "Given a country like the U.S., which has a collective attention span of 5 minutes, it is easy to see why people get bored."

Ironic Timing?
Of all weeks, Americans arguably should remain more attentive to al-Qaida claims now. The 9-11 anniversary is just a few days away, of course. And a London jury just today convicted three Islamic extremists for conspiracy to murder in a thwarted airplane-bomb attack.

In the case, prosecutors had argued that a group of British Muslims with ties to Pakistan had planned to use explosive hydrogen peroxide, disguised as a soft drink, to attack targets in the UK. But the jury could not reach a verdict on prosecutors' claims that they intended to target passenger jets flying from London to major North American cities with suicide attacks.

A jury in London found that Abdulla Ahmed Ali and coconspirators Assad Sarwar and Tanvir Hussain were guilty of conspiracy to murder by the use of hydrogen peroxide to make a bomb. But the jury failed to reach verdicts on charges against four other defendants. An eighth man was acquitted.

U.S. and British investigators stopped the attacks before they could materialize. But Venzke said that Americans should not assume that they are safe just because there have been no terror attacks on U.S. soil since 9-11.

"It's still al-Qaida," Venzke said. "It's still the group that killed 3,000 Americans."

Comments

Hard to believe it is seven years since that day. September 11th, 2001. I am a reporter working at a small-ish Left Wing Radio station, that happens to be on Wall Street. I was at the scene of the Trade Center buildings that day. Suddenly, the terror I felt in the pit of my belly in places like Guatemala, Panama and El Salvador, where I've covered stories of war and civil unrest, hit me like a ton of bricks. Yes, I do believe in what the writer asserts.... That is, many people here in the USA have become too lax of late, when it comes to these broadcasts, and postings, by the terrorist group. I am not an FBI guy so, what should we believe? Are we "winning" the war against O.B. Laden and company? What of the next RED Alert, should it come? Plus, many people, especially in New York City, are constantly bombarded with warnings of, "something terrible is about to happen. And we cannot tell you what it is, or even when, but, be vigilant." Or, "if you see something, say something." How do we Americans balance what the media and elected officials tell us, against living in a constant state of fear? And for me, I one who subscribes to the notion that a people, ANY people, who are constantly frightened are the easiest to control. I, like many of my friends and family hope that the good guys are winning. To live in a constant state of fear, like a lot of Americans do (especially in places NOT high on the list of targets) means, willy-nilly, that the terrorists are the ultimate winners in this game of cat and mouse. What gets me? Dr. Ayman al-Zazahiri and O.B. Laden can make more videos than Michael Jackson and, the FBI or CIA cannot find these guys? Something is wrong with that picture.      
This is exactly what should happen with the public attention concerning these terrorists. The terror only works if it makes people afraid. The experts and security personal can watch and react, but it's better to keep them out of minds eye where the public is concerned. I am not saying ignoring them will make them go away, but there is no need to let them hold us hostage. Not like they say anything new or interesting, just the same old garbage.
It's time to step up on our message to all Muslim countries. Al Qaeda not only demonizes America and the West, but now also brands as traitors the governments of Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, Iran and Afghanistan. It is time for Muslims around the world to understand that Al Qaeda thinks they they have a monopoly on "truth" and that they think everyone (Muslim and non-Muslim) who do not agree with them, or do not agree to give them absolute power, deserves death.

It is time for the entire world to reject them, and do what they can to capture them.
uh, maybe the Dept. Homeland Security, FBI, and CIA could pay attention to that stuff, and the U.S. public could take a break?
Vigilance is one thing, but should every kooky threat get jammed down my throat? Maybe just to ensure the GOP stays in office? Am I supposed to be out chasing these guys? I don't get it.

You'd think there would be some merit to these threats NOT being publicized. The idea is NOT to humor these people, NOT to give them a worldwide forum. How many times did the Unabomber try to get his silly thing published before someone finally did it?

Was the US gov. consumed with shark-week and the Levy disappearance too? What was THEIR excuse?

Finally - NEWSFLASH - try to actually FIND SOME NEWS on cable TV during August/September (or ever, anymore) - nobody can be bothered to report any of it. Sure, it's all on the website, but you guys can't pay some dunce to read it. It's more important to run LOCKUP: CORKOZONE 14 times in a row. Geez, you even took away the TICKER during the conventions for cryin' out loud. I can't even READ the news on TV while I'm NOT paying attention to the SAME 4 people commenting on the same THREE stories all day.

Oh, and yeah, sorry for my 7 year attention span... I noticed my grandparents haven't been keeping close watch over our Pacific naval interests lately too.
Huh? What, you mean those terrorists are still out there? There are still bombs going off in Baghdad? WEIRD, because I have to DIG TO FIND THAT INFO.

So yeah - sue us - the American people - for not paying closer attention.
Somehow I had this weird idea that the government would run the country and the news organizations would report the news. Instead, we're all on our own. Thank God for the interweb, or I'd have to join a cult or survivalist group or something.
It is sad to say that this is true, we are becoming complacent. This is a kick in the face to all who died on 9/11. Hopfully in this upcoming election we elect someone who will keep this in mind instead of rolling over belly up.
The God who made all of us loves all of us and calls us to love one another. Let us pray that we may open our minds and hearts to each other. Let us give up hating others who are different from us. May all of us be blessed by God and seek to be obedient to God.  
We better be listening. The events of 9-11 which changed my life happened because the "right people" weren't listening and poo poohed the concept that a large scale attack could take place on U.S. soil. Do not underestimate the power of hatred. We are talking about civilizations that have been around for thousands of years and warring for much of that history. Think about it: The 9-11 murderers sat in caves for five years and plotted this disaster. They trained, found funding, located weaknesses in our system, obtained the needed supplies and conspirators and carried it out with military precision. They made some timing mistakes( which saved numerous lives) and vastly underestimated American courage and ingenuity however,this nation should never again be on the defensive. We need to do whatever is in order to secure our borders, close these loopholes in security and begin treating foreigners the same way other nations treat aliens. Prove you are a benefit to this nation or we don't want you. Prove you have a right to be here legally or back you go. These monsters have one objective and that is to destroy western civilization, install sharia law and enslave us all. We better be listening.
You hear that America, the Democrats are calling you dim witted if you are a Republican or concerned about terrorism (read Michail Muellers comment).  If it doesn't have a hate Bush message, the elite Dem liberals  don't dismiss it.
How is it that you people are thanking president Bush for keeping you safe?  Did 9-11 not happen under his watch?  Do you really think we are safer having most of our military across the ocean?  Do you really think he has done a good job bankrupting our country on a war that hasnt even targeted the al-qaida?  We are on our way to becoming a completely monetarily poor country with weakened military and no money to build our national security back up not to mention the loss of soldiers lives......

Please Americans, let's look at the whole picture...our country will only be as strong as our weakest members.....ie.."middle class"
lets look out for every last person in our own country and actually Unite to have a strong nation internally and externally.  I also dont think it would hurt to have a likeable president to foreign countries....bullies are never liked and may become a target.  perhaps if the al-qaida likes our leader, we are at less risk.....
Excellent Article: Thanks for informing and updating.
Al Qaida "The Database" was created by our CIA.  FACT.

Why did all 9/11 attackers received their Visa's from one Consulate in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.  This US Consulate was under CIA control for Years, read Springman's testimony. Why has there never been a public trial of any 9/11 criminal.

If we are really in a war on Terror, why haven't we invaded Saudi Arabia, why haven't we invaded Pakistan.  Both Political Parties Rely on a mythical Boogieman, to keep society bound together by a common enemy.  This is the foundation of Neo-Conservative Reality, nothing is more important, NOT EVEN THE TRUTH, Mythology, is VITAL, Read Leo Strauss, the Guru of Neo-Con Theology.  
  In the eighties is was the exagerated threat of the Soviet Union, Today it is some invisible guy in a turban.  There are terrorists planning the next attack, but do we really know who or what they represent, and without an honest investigation into 9/11 the public will be mentally enslaved by the powers of propaganda.  
Wake up people, we are involved in WW III. If you have any doubt about are enemy and their goals read--Raymond Ibrahim's book The Al Qaeda Reader.  You will then understand.  The Islamic Fascists must be stopped, they are dedicated to the destruction of Western political and social beliefs and they will not accept compromise. NN
I don't think there is one person in the US who will be able to stop themselves from thinking about terrorism this week of all weeks.  

The media should take some responsibility.  I could not care less about Palin's daughter being pregnant.  Take the time from these salacious, but umimportant stories and spend some time on what people actually care about.  Issues.
I have sat here and listened to all the same talk. Each cell has their mission and it will happen again, it's a matter of where and when. We as American's need to focus on what we are about not what they are about. Our government is organized to watch listen and act. We as citizen need to be aware but not to change our way of life. That's what they want, change our thoughts and our ways, wrong answer, want some come get some. home of the proud and the brave. Media is another way of War.
A; “your boring me,” reaction to Al-Qaida propaganda may serve a purpose in downplaying extremist’s rhetoric, public hysteria, as well as negative Muslim stereotypes.   As far as preventing future attacks, media indifference would be no excuse for a failure of law enforcement to creatively track and infiltrate any terrorist organization.
I thought we were at war with these animals? It's been 8 years and we are no where? I thought we were the "ALMIGHTY" military nation that had satelitites that could look up a bugs ass and tell you what it ate for dinner(Maybe not a bugs ass but, one that could see vehicle license plates and what not).Also, if we have somewhat of a shred of information on where these peices of crap are training, then why do these place still exsist? Tell all the people in those areas" if you don't want to die, then come through this check point before we destroy this dump". I think that it's the leadership that's not co-ordinating and communicating the way that they should be that's going to get us into trouble. The candidate that just promises to kill Osama And Zawahiri gets my vote. Kill them two and stop the training.
Is there any wonder?  While the left railed against tapping phones in America a few years ago, Italy arrested 3 Algerians bound for the U.S. to take out what they figured to be around 10,000 people. This story was covered by every major news agency in the world, on the front page! Except, here in the U.S.! It didn't fit the cries of the left so they didn't feel that you needed to know about it. China, Russia, France, every country in the world except for the place that it was going to happen to. YOU weren't told because they caught them while tapping cell phones! Anyone that bothered to read the testimony of those that lived around the terrorist of 9/11 would know that there was 1 resounding statement. "They were on their cell phones all the time" !Unfortunately, our media has started to lean so far left, that they will stop at nothing to further that cause!
I know that the threat is real and growing. I tried to convince my wife to move to Baltimore DC area and she completly refused feeling that it was not safe due to the threat of a portable nuclear device and the crazed so-called "Jihad" that has been ensuing since the 80's. Man President Clinton really dropped the ball with the intel that he was given.

McCain 08
Are we listening?  Yes, when we are made aware that there is a new tape.  Do we live in fear?  No, sorry jihadists.
But, if we appear to be complacent and uninterested in the latest rantings, they just may decide to get our attention.
Playing the 9/11 videos at a political convention is apalling, and if you think that it was appropriate you are a very misguided person.  Using fear to get elected is not a respectable strategy, in fact, it is quite despicable.  Every one of us understands the need for security, and you can be assured both candidates running for president do.  The difference is one speaks of bettering ourselves and being a responsible country in the world, while the other is digging up old feelings to bombard us with fear.  Enough is enough.  Stop sucking on the teet of ignorance and start recognizing the truth.  Terrorism has been a part of this world for thousands of years and it is not going to go away.  It is something we have to live with and defend ourselves from, yes, but should NOT be used as a political tool.  I don't have all the answers but I do know when someone is deceiving me just to get the upper hand.  END the addiction for oil.  STOP the violence in our own culture.  SET AN EXAMPLE for the world instead of being the big, ignorant bully who thinks he has it all.  Metaphor or not, David brought down Goliath.  We are not invincible.
Not seeing these organizations at the forefront of our news everyday world seem to confirm we no longer want to promote their cause ... they love being out front ... they get attention and more followers ......  I am confident those who need to know ... know ... I would agree however we should simply take out the borders where the Al-Qaida is doing their training . and futher push back their timelines.  
I agree with Scott R- It's my feelings and belief that we are very much under attack as we speak. 9/11 led to the "out of the closet" Al-qaida.The Americans, Canadians, Britains and the rest of the free world have spent billions and billions of
$,driving the free world into Bankruptcy, Recession and Depression--I believe that this behaviour of Hit, Retreat, and wait, was and is the basic plan of Al-Qaida.The Media Highway is always open and you can bet Al-Qaida has'nt missed a single moment of it's content. The terrorists have all the time in the world: They have been waiting and preparing for hundreds of years for the closet door to open.We have fallen into the path and plans of those who knew we would and we should be very worried still, this not near over. Complacency is a very usefull weapon. RZ
I find this article rather interesting.  I think it is great that the media has moved on from fear mongering and giving these troglodytes a podium.  The reality is that the right people are indeed listening to all the chatter, and since the media can't prove otherwise because to do so would be to reveal our hand, you instead choose Joe Schmoe to be our litmus test.  The American people have to many other concerns that immediately affect our daily lives.  We live in a REPUBLIC, which means that we as a society delegate responsibility to selected candidates, trusting that they will be up to the task.  How can we as a society function if we are obsessed with what some lunatic in a cave said into a camera.  America, our society and its principles, has been the target of ignorants and fanatics for most of our history.  Sometimes these zealots have long beards or white hoods, sometimes they wear swastikas or carry a bible.  As long as we hold true to the principles set forth in our Constitution so long ago and see to it that our Republic never becomes a Theocracy we will always prevail, and this Great Nation shall not parish from this Earth.
At this point and time it does not matter if you are Dem. or Rep. Yes terrorism is very much a threat.  We all have to pull together as an United Staes if we are to defeat this threat.

John White Kingma Arizona
Should the general populace truly concern itself with what terrorist cells are doing the world over?  Nope. As a country, we barely notice our own presidential elections w/ nearly half the country not even bothering to vote in the 2004 Presidential election. What makes you think we are going to focus on one man speaking on the other side of the world proclaiming his hatred for this country?  

After everything is said and done, life will continue as it has since 9-11.  We are going to claim better security, a safer country and stronger vigilance but in the end, we will still be hated by most of the Middle East....  Moreover, yes we will still buy our oil from them.

How can you really tackle two wars in the Middle East, Iraq/Afghanistan, when the countries that oppose us have close relationships with the countries that keep us moving?
What gets me, as I read others comments, are what they say about Obama.  People, do you NOT listen.  He wants to go after Al-Qaida in the region they are now gaining in strength. They are leaving Iran, hence the VICTORY Bush is claiming in Iran. Repulicans say we went to Iran to fight terrorism, Hey guys, the terrorists went there because we were there.  Check the time line. We better pay attention to all the Al-Qaida leaders even if he is saying the same ole thing.  I don't think any of their messages (any part of it) should be aired in the US.  Never know when a code may be given to set things in motion. 9-11 eve, OH MY GOSH PEOPLE.  They need to show that every week, so you Republican idiots can remember what not listening to the "idiol chatter of Al-Qaida can do. By the way Republicans use the word liberal like it's a dirty word. Check old Mr. Webster.  It means Not narrow in opinion or judgment. Conserve (one of the meanings anyway)one prepared from a mixture of fruits. I'm Independent, Not easily influenced, showing self-reliance and personal freedom. PERSONAL FREEDOM, NOW THAT SHOUTS AMERICA TO ME. PERSONAL FREEDOM!
We better be listening, see what happen last time we ignored little things like messages picked up by the FBI and intel of the CIA. We got our shoved down our throats. Leave the troops and level the Mountains in Afganastan, and you will get the rest of those crazed that love death as per Bin Laden, we love life so let's show the little spoiled we mean business.
Al-Qaida is a group of murdering criminals period, that is all, akin to the Nazi's and Facsist. You damn right I am listening, and have been for years before and after 9-11. I don't listen to our inept, lying, government and ignore the moronic and pathetic US News media. Get educated in the real world (travel). I could care less about the idiot Republicans, Democrats make me want to puke, and do nothing Washington, that has has not minded the store in so long I can't remember when they did.  As usual, what pathetic choices this election. This is the end result when corporations run this country and everything else. WAKE UP!!! It was once the United States of America, it is now the Corporate States of America. As horrible and devastating as 9-11 was and still is, it will happen again...we have not learned a damn thing. We are too worried about American Idol and what Angelina Jolie is wearing, be concerned with what happens to our country and economy. Oh, that's right, we sold out to the Chinese and India, and the Middle East. Se'la vie.
Of course your asking if anyone is still listening your job depends on people listening.  I would imagine that our govt is listening to the messages pretty closly (although to no profit to the media giants) and thats all that really matters.  This is exactly why this message won't be posted on the blog.
Oh please...just because the media hasn't hyped it doesn't mean it isn't getting attention. Why should we show this tape freely through western media thereby allowing Al-Qaida hijack our very lives? I'll keep my self-defense tools loaded and sharpened and let the professional defense system alert me to imminent threat. Otherwise, there are precious few minutes in the day and I refuse to give fear and hate the focus of more of them than is absolutely necessary.
All i know is that if the US wanted to eliminate Al Qaida they could in a heart beat. This is all just nonsensical complacency of the US Military. THey could easily crush them with a swift blow but then their war on terror would be over.... and nobody to invade or attack and that means the money flow stops.... Just kill them already and this will all be over


Send a comment

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Your name, city and state (John Doe, Seattle, Wash.): 

Your e-mail address (jdoe@msnbc.com):

Your website (it's okay if you don't have one):

Remember me? (We'll keep it private)

About the blog

Deep Background is NBC News’ investigative blog. It covers national security, terrorism, spies, Iraq, and politics, as well as government waste, fraud and abuse. It is edited by NBC News Senior Investigative Producer Jim Popkin.

Archives


Browse by topic:

Add this blog to your news reader