We're FEMA and we're here to help

Posted on Wednesday, February 20, 2008 7:07 PM ET
Filed Under:

By Robert Windrem and Dan Linden 

If the sky is falling, FEMA is prepared to catch it.

That was the message from FEMA - the agency made famous by its anemic response to Hurricane Katrina - to the threat posed by a spy satellite that could soon come crashing to Earth.

FEMA has produced a memo and 18-page guide, a “First Responder Guide for Space Object Re-Entry,” that have been sent to thousands of local police, fire and emergency service agencies around the country.  It also has helpful hints for the public.

FEMA also has placed six “Federal Joint Interagency Task Forces” on alert in FEMA regions, ready to be deployed, just in case, according to the FEMA memo. A “Consequence Management Group” has been assembled at the Department of Homeland Security’s National Operations Center in Washington to manage the crisis, the memo adds.

There will be real-time contact with the Pentagon tonight during a planned shoot-down of the spy satellite, and even a FEMA representative at the DoD operations center, a FEMA spokesman says.

So why is FEMA even involved, at taxpayer expense?

Military and space experts doubt that debris from the spy satellite - about the size of a legendary FEMA trailer - will hit anywhere near land. Moreover, assuming the Pentagon’s shoot-down is successful, the most likely consequence would be a “meteor shower” of small bits of debris north of Vancouver. As in Canada.

Neither the memo nor the guide, sent out Wednesday, takes into account the Pentagon shoot-down. It’s not even mentioned, a week after the Pentagon announced the ambitious plan to great fanfare. The FEMA documents are written as if the satellite will fall to earth, intact. But even if that happened, experts say, the consequences would be limited to a debris shower that would look like shooting stars.

“The debris cloud would cross the dark Canadian coast north of Vancouver 15 minutes after the shoot-down,” said Jim Oberg, NBC’s space analyst.  “I expect that some of the most energetically expelled fragments will be hitting the atmosphere all along this track. It could be a meteor shower to remember.”

Nonetheless, the FEMA documents make it sound as if all of America could be at risk.

“Some of you may find yourself dealing with this issue within your community and response area,” reads the memo from FEMA’s Disaster Operations Directorate. It adds: “Please keep in mind that the probability that it will fall upon the United States is low, yet we must be ready.”

In the guide, FEMA warns first responders to avoid coming in contact with, inhaling or swallowing any of the chemicals that could survive the descent through the atmosphere.  Should the satellite strike a tank truck, watch out, it cautions. “Consider evacuation for 800 meters (0.5 miles) in all directions,” it says. And if someone is hurt by the falling debris, “call 9-1-1 or emergency medical services”.

There are also helpful hints for the public: “Citizens who observe or encounter falling debris should notify your local public safety agency and stay away from it.”

Tonight, FEMA is unapologetic about its efforts and says these are the kinds of precautions the agency should be taking.

“This is what we do," said Russ Knocke, a spokesman for the Department of Homeland Security, which oversees FEMA.  "We've been on this for weeks," Knocke said, adding that FEMA’s philosophy with potential national disasters is: “Take no chances, and spare no expense.

"This is one of several issues that are on our plate at the National Operations Center this evening," added Knocke, along with watching the U.S. ports, borders, and potentially dangerous weather. "In terms of planning and coordination, that's something we do on a daily basis."

Knocke could not offer any estimates tonight on how much money the agency is spending on the first-responder guide or the overall falling-satellite operation.

Dan Linden is a production assistant at NBC Nightly News.

Comments

If FEMA did nothing and it fell on our heads, you guys would be all over them.  They go through the trouble of preparing for something that is a possibility, and you put in a dumb statement such as "So why is FEMA even involved, at taxpayer expense?"    Frankly I'm glad they're considering the possibility, even if it means they have to spend some of my tax dollars.
Ok - FEMA wasn't prepared for Katrina - preparedness which costs money - and throughly chastised for their failure (no matter how much should have also been shouldered by other agencies and governmental entities - now let's chastise them for being prepared....
The motto of some "wanna be" press people - "Thou shalt find no good in anything and shall only write with negativity" so people will know what a wonderful reporter I am.
I wonder if this jerk - excuse me, "reporter" - will be on hand if this preparedness is needed?? Probably not; but he will be searching high and low to report how FEMA was not prepared....
Hey FEMA;
If your CCD from the satellite falls in my back yard, I'm going to sell the sucker.
Hey, man. (Crew)

Have fun, good shot, man (crew). Let the Ruskies (and china) dwell on that.

Shame we didn't do it first, but you did do it, after all. Well enough.

One shot, One kill. (Right?)

Spot on.
Does anyone still think that its just toxic fuel there worried about? The brainiac's at the Pentagon have "special" material on board and don't want to irradiate Oregon. We need a Federal Government like we need a third nostril. Boneheads!  
FEMA?

2 jokes:

1)Theyre Prepared

2)They say they're going to CLEAN UP SOMETHING!!


thats all!
FEMA makes it sound like we Americuns ern't to smart!  They spent HOW MUCH money putting THAT together??

"“This is what we do," said Russ Knocke, a spokesman for the Department of Homeland Security, which oversees FEMA.  "We've been on this for weeks," Knocke said, adding that FEMA’s philosophy with potential national disasters is: “Take no chances, and spare no expense."

"So why is FEMA even involved, at taxpayer expense?"

Was this a rhetorical question, or are you *really* that ignorant?
Sounds like another episode of X-Files
I heard that Oklahoma is one possible area where the debris from the satelite may fall.  I am concerned about this not only because I live in OKC, OK but because I dreamed a couple of weeks ago that it did actually fall here.  While I am sure you don't operate on information from dreams as a source, I also know that in this situation no source is scientifically reliable.
ORSON WELLS & THE MERCURY THEATRE(THEY OF THR WAR OF THE WORLDS BROADCAST OF THE 1930'S) WOULD BE ENVIOUS OF THIS SCI-FI HOAX. JUST ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF A TOTALLY INEPT BUSH PROGRAM !! FORGET ABOUT FLOODS, TORNADOES & HURRICANES ARE REAL THREATS ARE FROM SPACE JUNK. THE SKY IS FALLING!!!THE SKY IS FALLING!!!  
You media people kill me !  If something did happen, you'd all be screaming "They knew this would happen, why didn't they plan for it, why weren't the ready  ?"  And the way the MEDIA, has been reporting this thing, it did sound a lot worse than it apparently is... Has the media apologized for being over zealous in its reporting ??? No.
I'm usually up for jokes at the expense of any federal agency.  However, I'm glad there is a liaison between the Pentagon and local first responders when we know something out-of-the-ordinary is happening.  Any number of things could go wrong with the shoot-down.  It seems appropriate to me that FEMA should have some involvement.
If you did your research, you would have found that FEMA has been on standby for a number of these missions in the past, including Space Shuttle Missions, Space Shuttle Recovery; national events such as Papal Visits, Super Bowls etc.
FEMA can't win.  If they prepare and get information out, they get criticized for spending taxpayer money.  If they do nothing, they get abused for doing nothing.  Way to go, MSNBC.  Great story, compelling and rich.
Check a response to this by Rich Cooper, a former DHS and NASA official who thinks that FEMA's actions were more than approrpriate: securitydebrief.adfero.com
Let us dissect the acronym that is FEMA...
Federal Emergency Management Agency. If potentially toxic debris is falling out of the sky I think that would be an emergency. FEMA's stated mission is to prepare, respond, recover and mitigate disasters to include "a hurricane, an earthquake, a tornado, a flood, a fire or a hazardous spill, an act of nature or an act of terrorism." Way to go MSNBC you missed the mark on reliable reporting.


Send a comment

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Your name, city and state (John Doe, Seattle, Wash.): 

Your e-mail address (jdoe@msnbc.com):

Your website (it's okay if you don't have one):

Remember me? (We'll keep it private)

About the blog

Deep Background is NBC News’ investigative blog. It covers national security, terrorism, spies, Iraq, and politics, as well as government waste, fraud and abuse. It is edited by NBC News Senior Investigative Producer Jim Popkin.

Archives


Browse by topic:

Add this blog to your news reader